In the serene and simple lives of the Amish, the concept of love transcends modern-day complexities and digital distractions. In the heart of America’s pastoral landscapes, the Amish communities foster relationships that are as deep and enduring as the soil they till. Here, amidst the clip-clop of horse-drawn buggies and the golden hues of harvest, blossoms unique love stories that echo the principles of simplicity, integrity, and faith. These narratives are about finding love and living it with a quiet steadfastness that is as refreshing as a spring breeze through the open fields.
We will explore the charming and surprising world of Amish community, where every heart beats with a rhythm as steady as a handcrafted grandfather clock, and every romance is a proof to timeless devotion. Whether you’re a fan of sweet, gentle romances or you’re curious about a different way of life, these stories are sure to warm your heart. So, let’s visit the world of Amish love and discover the beauty in simplicity.
7 Amish Love Stories You Must Read
The premise of Amish stories involves forbidden love or the tension between following one’s heart and staying true to family or community norms, which is a compelling narrative device. They satisfy a curiosity about the Amish lifestyle, which is private and distinct from mainstream American culture. This includes their customs, traditions, and how they face love and relationships within tightly knit communities. Here are 7 such love stories includes those looking for gentler romantic content. Let’s read!
1. A Tale of Two Worlds
Author: Hannah Lapp.
Characters: Hannah, Bishop Jacob.
Hello, dear friend. My name is Hannah Lapp, and today, I want to take you on a journey—a journey that’s both mine and maybe a little bit yours, too. It’s a story of discovery, of finding where I truly belong, and of daring to step into the unknown, even when it’s terrifying.
I grew up in a place where life was simple, where tradition wasn’t just important—it was everything. In our Amish community, we lived by the old ways, and the ways of our ancestors, and those ways were meant to be unchangeable. But ever since I was a little girl, I felt like there was a tiny whisper inside me telling me I was somehow different. But why? I couldn’t quite figure it out.
The day that changed everything started like any other. I was preparing for my marriage to Bishop Jacob, a man our community respected deeply. But as I was going through my parents’ attic, sorting through old things, I found something that stopped me in my tracks. It was a satin baby dress—delicate, beautiful, and completely out of place in our world. It wasn’t Amish; it was something from the English world, the world we were taught to keep at arm’s length.
That dress sparked a fire inside me, a fire made of curiosity and a feeling I couldn’t shake. I needed to know more. So I began to ask questions—quietly at first, but then more insistently. And finally, my parents told me the truth that had been hidden from me all my life: I wasn’t born into the Amish world. I was adopted. My birth mother was English, and after she passed away, I was brought into this community and raised by the only parents I had ever known.
Imagine how that felt. The ground beneath me seemed to vanish, and everything I thought I knew about myself was suddenly uncertain. But there was something else, too—a small sense of relief. Finally, I understood why I always felt a little bit different. But this truth didn’t bring just clarity; it also brought a storm of confusion.
I decided I couldn’t ignore what I had learned. At my sister’s wedding, I made a choice that would forever change my place in the community. I wore that satin dress, and I played the guitar—a beautiful instrument but one forbidden by our rules. I didn’t do it out of rebellion. I did it to honor the mother I never knew, to connect with the part of me that came from her. But the reaction was swift and harsh. The community shunned me, turning away as if I had vanished. The people I had known all my life now acted as if I didn’t exist.
That was the darkest time in my life. I was alone, isolated, and full of questions. I struggled with the pain of being cut off from everything I knew, and yet, there was a part of me that couldn’t deny who I was or where I came from. I needed to know more about my past to understand my future.
So, I made a decision that broke my heart—I left the Amish community. I left behind my family, my friends, and everything familiar. Stepping into the English world was like stepping off a cliff into the unknown. But I knew that to find peace, I needed to take that leap. It wasn’t only a journey to a new place; it was a journey into myself, into understanding and accepting all the pieces that made me who I am.
Leaving meant I might never see my family again. The thought of that was almost too much to bear, but the need to reconcile my past with my future was even stronger. And so, I stepped out, not with defiance, but with hope—a hope that in this new world, I might finally find where I truly belong.
This is my story, Hannah’s story—a story of courage, discovery, and the search for belonging. It’s a story about finding the strength to walk a path that isn’t easy but that’s true to who you are. And I share it with you in the hope that it might inspire you, too, to listen to that small voice inside and to take your own journey, wherever it may lead.
Thank you for listening to my story.
Tropes:
- Fish Out of Water.
- The Big Secret.
- Forbidden Love.
- Breaking the Rules.
- Coming of Age.
- The Quest for Identity.
- Culture Clash.
- Shunning.
2. Love Between the Lines
Author: Rebecca Miller
Characters: Rebecca, Ethen.
I’m Rebecca Miller, and I guess you could say I’ve always been a bit of an odd duck compared to the other girls in our Amish community. You see, while they’re all dreaming about making quilts and driving buggies, my heart has always been somewhere else—lost in the pages of a good book. Oh yeah, the local library is my absolute haven. It’s that magical place where I can visit worlds created by words, where I can live lives so different from the ones I know.
Now, let me tell you about a day that started out like any other but ended up changing everything. I was tucked away in a dusty corner of the library, like usual, when something caught my eye. It was an old, worn journal, hiding among the books that no one seemed to pay much attention to. Oh, the writings inside! They were full of pain and beauty like the author had poured their soul onto the pages. I couldn’t explain it, but I felt this deep connection to whoever had penned those words, like we were kindred spirits, both tangled up in our own worlds.
And you know what? That’s when things started getting really interesting. Around the same time, this guy named Ethen started showing up at the library more and more. Ethen, with his quiet way and that deep, introspective look in his eyes. He was one of those people who seemed to carry the weight of the world on his shoulders, ya know? We’d known each other in passing before, but now, we seemed to be drawn together, like two lonely souls finding comfort in shared silence.
As we started talking more, oh boy, did we hit it off. We’d share little bits of our lives, our struggles, and the things that helped us escape, like the books I loved so much. I found myself drawn to Ethen in ways I never expected, but there was always this invisible wall around him like he was holding back. It was like he was keeping a part of himself hidden, and I couldn’t quite figure out why.
Then came the bombshell. One day, as I was flipping through that old journal, something clicked. I realized that Ethen was the author. The journal was his, and it was filled with his grief over losing his brother—a brother he believed he could have saved. It was like everything suddenly made sense, but it also shook me to my core.
Confronting Ethen about the journal? That was one of the hardest things I’ve ever done. We stood there, surrounded by the quiet shelves and the whispers of secrets long buried, and we laid it all out on the table. He opened up about his guilt and his sorrow, and I shared my own dreams and fears. At that moment, we didn’t only see each other as friends—or even as two people who might fall in love—but as companions in this crazy journey of healing and finding peace.
It was in that honest moment that I realized the love I’d been searching for was right there in front of me, wrapped up in shared pain and understanding. Ethen and I, we made a choice. We decided to embrace our future together, flaws and all. We knew that life would throw challenges our way—of course it would! But we also knew that facing those challenges together made us stronger.
So, here we are, hand in hand, ready to write our own story. It’s a story of love, acceptance, and the courage to step forward, even when the path isn’t clear. And I wouldn’t have it any other way.
Thanks for letting me share my story with you. Life’s a bit like a book, isn’t it? You never know what the next chapter will bring, but it sure helps when you’ve got someone by your side to turn the pages with.
Story Tropes:
- Secret Past.
- Bookworm Meets Bad Boy.
- Healing Through Love.
- Mysterious Diary.
- Opposites Attract.
- Small Town Charm.
- Second Chances.
3. A Slice of Forgiveness
Author: Emma Miller
Characters: Ruby, Daniel.
Hey, friend! I’ve got a story for you that’s as warm and comforting as a slice of pie—literally. It’s about a young guy named Daniel, who’s had a pretty rocky start in life. You see when Daniel was a little kid, his dad left him. Yeah, it was a tough pill to swallow. Fast forward to today, and Daniel’s been living with this incredibly kind Amish family, the Grabbers. They’ve taken him in and treated him like one of their own. But, even with all that love, there’s this heavy feeling in Daniel’s heart that he just can’t shake—the feeling of being abandoned.
Now, enter Ruby. Oh, Ruby—she’s got a heart of gold, and she’s totally into Daniel. She sees something special in him that he can’t quite see in himself. But here’s the kicker: Daniel is so wrapped up in his own world of hurt and those nagging questions about his past that he’s kind of blind to the amazing future he could have with Ruby. And to make things more interesting, there’s this family recipe for something called “White Christmas Pie.” It’s more than a dessert; it’s got a hidden message of its own.
Just when it feels like Daniel’s life is at a standstill, bam! A letter shows up out of the blue. But this isn’t just any old letter—it’s from his dad. Yeah, the dad who took off years ago. You can imagine how that stirs things up. Suddenly, Daniel’s faced with a choice he never saw coming: does he hang on to all that bitterness and all those questions that have been weighing him down, or does he find it in his heart to forgive his dad and move forward?
Oh man, it’s a tough decision. Forgiveness isn’t only about saying the words, you know? It’s about really letting go of all that heavy stuff that’s been dragging you down. It’s about finding peace. Daniel’s not alone, though. Ruby’s there, with her big heart, and so is his Amish family, supporting him every step of the way.
In the end, Daniel makes the brave choice to forgive. It’s not easy—oh no, it’s far from easy—but it’s the right thing to do. And when he does, something incredible happens. He starts to realize that family isn’t only about who shares your blood. It’s about the people who stand by you, who love you even when things get tough.
And as for that White Christmas Pie? Well, it turns out to be more than a recipe. It’s a symbol of forgiveness, fresh starts, and new beginnings, just in time for the holidays. As Daniel takes that first bite, it’s like he’s also taking the first step into a future filled with hope and love, surrounded by the people who really matter.
Thanks for sticking with me through Daniel’s story. I hope it reminds you that, no matter how heavy the past might feel, there’s always a chance for a fresh start—and maybe even a sweet slice of pie to go along with it.
Story Tropes:
- Found Family.
- Forgiveness.
- Love Is Right in Front of You.
- The Power of a Letter.
- Secret Recipe.
- Healing Journey.
4. From City Lights to Amish Nights
Author: Anna Fisher
Characters: Luna, Mary, Jacy.
Two sisters, Luna and Mary, are living their best lives in the hustle and bustle of New York City. They’re all about the fast-paced lifestyle, you know? The noise, the lights, the endless possibilities. But then, out of nowhere, life throws them a curveball. After their mom passes away (a devastating blow, no doubt), they suddenly find themselves packing up and moving to Lancaster County to live with their Amish aunt Rebecca and Uncle Daniel. Yep, you read that right—goodbye, skyscrapers, and hello, farmland.
Now, if you’re imagining a major culture shock, you’re absolutely right. Especially for Luna, the older sister. She’s got dreams of becoming a fashion designer, and the Amish community isn’t exactly known for their runway shows. Moving to a place where the biggest excitement is a community quilting event? Yeah, it’s like she’s been dropped on a different planet. Mary, her younger sister, is a bit more open to this new adventure, but even she’s got her reservations.
Their Aunt Rebecca is this incredibly kind and patient woman, the kind of person who makes you feel at home even when everything around you is strange. She starts teaching the girls about the Amish way of life—simplicity, family, faith. It’s a whole new world for Luna and Mary, and honestly, it’s not an easy adjustment. Rebecca also gives them something really special: their late Aunt Jacy’s journals. These journals are like a window into Jacy’s soul, filled with her thoughts, dreams, and reflections.
As you can imagine, the girls face a ton of challenges as they try to fit into this new life. Luna, in particular, struggles hard. She’s constantly missing her old life, her friends, the energy of the city, and those Amish rules. Way too strict for her taste. Mary, on the other hand, starts to adapt a little quicker, which only makes Luna feel more out of place.
But here’s where things get interesting. Luna stumbles across something in Jacy’s journals—something big, something that could change the way the Amish community sees their family. It’s one of those moments where you’re like, “Whoa, what’s she gonna do?” She’s faced with a tough decision: does she spill the secret and potentially shake things up, or does she keep it to herself to protect her new family?
In the end, Luna makes a choice that shows how much she’s grown. She realizes that family and love are way more important than any secret. She decides to protect her Amish family, learning a lot about forgiveness and acceptance in the process. It’s not an easy journey, but it’s one that brings her and Mary closer together. They start to find a new sense of belonging, and even Luna, the fashionista, begins to appreciate the simple life.
Luna eventually finds a way to blend her passion for fashion with the Amish influences around her, creating something truly unique. And Mary? She finds peace in the slower pace, something she never thought she’d enjoy. Aunt Rebecca’s gift of Jacy’s journals turns out to be a guiding light, helping the girls see the beauty in their new world, one they never expected to call home.
So, that’s their story—Luna and Mary, two city girls who found something precious in the quiet fields of Lancaster County. It’s a reminder that even when life takes us in a completely unexpected direction, there’s always something valuable to be found if we open our hearts to it. Thanks for reading, and I’d love to hear if any of you have had similar experiences of finding beauty in the unexpected!
Story Tropes:
- Fish Out of Water.
- The Power of Diaries.
- Cultural Clash.
- Secrets and Revelations:.
- Finding Where You Belong.
- The Mentor.
- Growth and Forgiveness.
5. Secrets in Amish Country
Author: Mary Elizabeth Stoltzfus
Characters: Hannah, Ethan.
Ever had life suddenly taken a sharp left turn on you? I just finished a book that hit me right in the feels because that’s exactly what happens to the main character, Hannah Byler. She’s living a peaceful, predictable life in Amish country—until, out of the blue, everything she thought she knew gets turned upside down.
Hannah’s your typical Amish girl, right? She’s got the routine down: chores, church, family time. But lately, she’s been noticing something off about her mom. It’s like this cloud is hanging over her—she’s sad, distracted, and not herself. Hannah, being super close to her mom, can feel that something’s up, but no matter how much she nudges or asks, her mom stays tight-lipped. It’s frustrating and, honestly, a little scary.
Meanwhile, everyone’s buzzing about Hannah’s upcoming marriage to her boyfriend, Ethan. It’s all anyone can talk about, but with her mom acting so strange, Hannah’s excitement is getting overshadowed by this growing sense of worry.
And then, her mom disappears. No warning, no note, nothing. One day, she’s there, and the next, she’s gone. The whole Amish community is rocked. But no one is more shaken than Hannah. She’s heartbroken, confused, and left with a million questions. Why did her mom leave? Where did she go? And why didn’t she say goodbye?
Unable to let it go, Hannah starts digging into her family’s past, desperate for answers. And what does she find? It’s a doozy. Her mom has been carrying around a secret so heavy that it’s been slowly crushing her. A secret that, once revealed, could change everything for Hannah’s family—and their entire community.
Now, Hannah’s got a choice to make. Does she keep this secret buried, protecting her family from the fallout? Or does she face it head-on, even if it means turning her life—and her community—upside down?
In the end, Hannah decides to do the bravest thing she’s ever done: she leaves. She steps away from the only life she’s ever known, determined to find her mom and heal the rift that’s torn her family apart. It’s terrifying, but she knows it’s the only way to find peace for herself and for her mom, too.
The story ends on a note of hope, with Hannah venturing into the unknown, ready to face whatever comes next. It’s a powerful reminder that sometimes, to find the answers we need, we have to step out of our comfort zones and face the truth, no matter how hard it might be.
Story Tropes:
- Family Secrets.
- Leaving Home.
- Mysterious Disappearance.
- Forbidden Love.
- The Quest for Truth.
- Culture Clash.
6. The Quilted Heart
Author: Rebecca Fisher
Characters: Rosy, Micah.
Imagine living in a place where life is peaceful and predictable, and everyone knows everyone. That’s what it’s like in Lancaster County, a serene Amish community where life runs on faith, family, and tradition. But as we all know, life has a way of throwing curveballs when you least expect them. That’s exactly what happens to two sisters, Rosy and Hena.
Rosy Ann Kauffman is our main girl—a young Amish woman with a kind heart and a deep love for her family. Life for Rosy has always been pretty straightforward. She’s grounded in her Amish faith, helping out with the daily chores, and cherishing the simple joys of life. But let’s be real, things are never as simple as they seem.
Rosy’s best friend, Hena (which is short for Hannah), is starting to feel the itch of curiosity, especially about what life could be like beyond the Amish community. Hena’s facing her own struggles, mainly with her family’s strict rules. She’s got this growing feeling that there’s more out there, and it’s causing a lot of tension at home. You can feel the push and pull she’s experiencing, stuck between what she’s always known and what she’s beginning to dream about.
Meanwhile, Rosy finds herself in the middle of a love triangle that she totally doesn’t see coming. On one side, there’s Nick—her childhood best friend who’s always been there for her, the steady rock in her life. On the other side, there’s Silas—a newcomer who stirs something new and exciting in Rosy’s heart. It’s one of those classic dilemmas: do you choose the comfort of what’s familiar or take a chance on something new?
As Hena’s curiosity about the outside world grows stronger, she starts pushing back against the Amish way of life. The tension keeps building, and you can feel the weight of her struggle. She loves her family, but she can’t ignore her desire to explore what’s out there.
Then, everything hits a breaking point. Hena makes a bold move that shocks everyone—she decides to leave the Amish community. This decision doesn’t only shake up her life; it turns Rosy’s world upside down too. Rosy’s dealing with her own love life drama, and now she’s worried sick about her best friend, wondering if she’ll ever see her again.
In the end, Rosy has a moment of clarity about her love life. She realizes that her heart truly belongs to Nick. It’s one of those sweet revelations where you figure out that sometimes, the best things in life have been right in front of you all along. Choosing Nick feels like coming home.
As for Hena, her departure is a huge wake-up call, not only for her family but for the entire community. It’s tough on everyone, but it also forces Rosy to take a closer look at her own life and choices. Hena’s journey into the outside world is filled with challenges, but it’s also a necessary step for her to find out who she really is.
Back in Lancaster, Rosy’s family and the Amish community slowly begin to heal from the disruptions caused by all these changes. They start to realize that accepting change and understanding differences can be a way to grow, even when it’s difficult.
Story Tropes:
- Forbidden Love.
- The Rebel.
- Best Friends Forever.
- Finding Yourself.
- Home Sweet Home.
- Culture Clash.
7. The Promise of Harvest
Author: Elizabeth Miller
Characters: July, Jonah
July Lapp was the kind of girl who believed in dreams—the kind that felt as real as the soil under your feet and the sky above your head. She had always imagined her life unfolding like one of those soft, sweet Amish romances. But as any of us who’ve lived a little know, life has a funny way of surprising you, of throwing a wrench in your carefully laid plans.
July was planning to marry Leo Fisher, a man who, for a time, seemed like he stepped straight out of her dreams. Tall, kind, with hands that could mend a broken fence and a smile that could mend a broken heart. They were the talk of the community—everyone knew they were meant to be. Or so they thought.
But here’s the thing about small communities: they’re a lot like beehives. Bustling, busy, full of life, but also full of buzzing opinions and the occasional sting. And July’s family? Well, they were at the center of this hive.
Her father, always the strong, silent type, had a heart that was starting to give him trouble. It was the kind of news that no one wanted to hear, least of all July, who had always seen him as the rock of their family. The farm, the land they’d lived on and loved for generations, was beginning to feel like a burden. Menno, July’s brother, had his heart set on bees, of all things. He’d spend hours with them, more interested in their hives than in the farm that was the backbone of their lives. And then there was Sadie, the dreamer, caught up in her own whirlwind of romantic fantasies, not quite grounded in the reality of what their family was facing.
Just as July thought she could finally focus on her wedding, life decided to throw her another curveball. Leo, her Leo, the man she’d dreamed of marrying, suddenly wasn’t so sure about their future. He’d been spending time with this mysterious beekeeping mentor, Rumy Troyer. Rumy, or the Bee Man as folks around town called him, had this way about him—quiet, wise like he understood things on a deeper level than most.
Rumy came to town to help with Menno’s bees, but he ended up doing a whole lot more than that. He was the kind of person who didn’t just hear you; he listened. And as the Lapp family’s troubles grew, Rumy seemed to be the calm in their storm. His advice wasn’t loud or forceful, but it had a way of making you stop and think. He helped July see her life in a new light, and before long, she found herself leaning on him in ways she hadn’t expected.
As for Leo, Rumy’s wisdom had him questioning everything—what he wanted, what love really meant, and whether he was truly ready for marriage. It wasn’t easy for July to hear Leo’s doubts, but in a way, it was the wake-up call she needed. Love, she realized, wasn’t only about weddings and romance. It was about family, about understanding, and sometimes, about letting go.
In the end, Leo found his way back to July, but it wasn’t the fairytale ending she’d always imagined. It was better. It was real. They came together not out of a sense of duty or tradition but out of a deep, honest love that had weathered the storms of uncertainty. And Rumy? Well, the Bee Man moved on, like a breeze that comes and goes, but not without leaving a lasting impact. He didn’t just mend bee hives; he helped mend hearts.
The Lapp family, with all their struggles and heartaches, came out stronger on the other side. The farm, which had once seemed like too much to handle, became a symbol of their resilience. Together, they faced their challenges, and together, they found a way forward.
July’s story is a reminder that life isn’t always what you expect. But with a little love, a lot of understanding, and the right people by your side, you can make it through anything.
Story Tropes:
- Love Triangle.
- The Mentor.
- Family Drama.
- Finding Yourself.
- Community and Belonging.
- Healing.
Last Words
And there you have it! A peek into the world of Amish—where love is pure, simple, and deeply rooted in faith and community. These stories remind us that sometimes, it’s the quiet moments, the simple gestures, and the deep connections that make love truly special. Happy reading, and don’t forget to share which story touched your heart the most! Until next time, keep love simple and sweet!
Read more:
15 Short Romantic Love Stories
7 Heart-wrenching Break Up Stories
Table of Contents
